I just got finished reading that Time Out Beijing, one of the city’s preeminent English-language entertainment guides, has been suspended indefinitely.
Not, as one might guess, because it had been publishing subvert-the-youth articles or anything of the sort – but simply because it wasn’t properly licensed.
I mean, in pretty much any country you’d need proper business licenses and if you didn’t have them, you could be shut down for any number of legalities. That’s not too bizarre.
But the part that I think is… amusing (?)… is that the magazine was operating just fine for more than three years without complaint, or proper forms filled in.
And again, there’s nothing wrong with the Chinese government tightening control over what has long been a wishy-washy practice of handing out the “most convenient” visa, rather than the “proper” one.
But therein lies the frustrating part in all this. As foreigners we come to China and know nothing of the local practices. We largely come from countries that follow the rule of law to an obsessive ‘t’, and so are eager to step in line and fill out the forms.
But upon arriving here we are faced with a fuzzy collection of rules and regulations that are not so much seen as just “known”. Rules which force us to rely on locals that have experience navigating this confusing and twisted clusterfuck of undocumented legalities that ebb and flow based largely on who you know, rather than what you know.
And before you know it, you’re just as tangled up in the mess as the rest of the country, jumping from relationship after relationship like fast sinking stones in a futile effort to ford a river you had no idea was so cold, deep and murky.
It all reminds me of a section of Tim Clissold’s excellent memoir, Mr. China, in which he relays the story of his brother’s visit while he was living on-campus at a Beijing university. Clissold hadn’t asked permission for his brother to stay in the room and took an earful from the dorm chief because of it. The following day he dutifully went to the dormitory office to ask about any other regulations he wasn’t aware of and didn’t want to break:
I wanted to avoid any more exhausting scenes like the last, so I called through the little hatch to the dormitory chief and politely asked for a copy of the rules. He said that I couldn’t have them, so I asked, “Why not?”
“Those rules are internal and not to be told to the outside.”
“What does that mean? If I don’t know what the rules are, how can I obey them?”
“Our regulations are very clear.”
“Oh, I’m sorry, but that’s not my point.” I replied. “If I don’t know what rules you have, I can’t follow them.” After a few more rounds, I gave up. I never did get a copy. I discovered years later that this “internal rule” concept was applied across the board in China, even to things like income tax. It’s hardly surprising that China’s tax system is so inefficient when no one knows what they’re meant to be paying.
As an anecdote it’s rather humorous, but when having to deal with it in your day-to-day, it’s enough to make any laowai a little loopy.
So, what’s the point of it? Why have such a diluted and befuddled system?
In my opinion, I think it’s a remnant of times past – whereby knowledge, and the power it brought with it, was something to be carefully guarded and controlled at all levels.
For most of us, the world’s knowledge, past and present, is a Google-search away, and that’s a perfectly acceptable part of modern existence. However, as any that have smacked up against the Great Firewall will tell you, in China things are *different*.
Individual empowerment is a relatively new concept in China, and the leadership seems to have an inherent mistrust of it. If given the choice and ability, it is assumed that the average person will inevitably make the wrong decision. And as such, you have the world’s most populated country essentially being treated as no more than children in the eyes of their
And do parents sit down and list out all the rules for their kids? Nope – generally they just punish them when the rules are broken. Using the act of breaking them and ensuing punishment as a lesson that they should be wary and cautious of all their actions.
Additionally, by keeping the ropes loose the majority of the time, it gives the powers that be something to tighten when needed.
And I think that’s exactly what we’re seeing now. The rules were always there, but are only now being enforced. It has turned regular folks into victims, and victims into criminals. And when you’re a criminal, you deserve the full attention and swift justice of Chinese *law*. Right?